Fathom Bistro, Bait & Tackle
House sausages and bait on a fishing pier
74Dennis Borlek spotted a shuttered building on the Shelter Island fishing pier while walking his dog in 2012, called the number in the window, and opened Fathom in 2013. It still sells bait. The kitchen makes its own sausages and grinds its own burger beef, and the taps rotate local craft beer with the bay all around.
OrderThe chicken pot pie sausage, under turkey gravy, with a local beer.
Your ratingNot rated
Before you go
- Bait shop too
- Outdoor seating on the pier
Last checked 2026-10. Hours change, so check before you go.